Taylor drafted Jordan Love in the 12th round and never started him. Poles started him four times and got 84 points. Connor called Love the best pick of the round. The funny thing is that Taylor can be right about Love on draft night and still have exactly zero to show for being right.
That’s the argument inside Jason and Connor’s draft lookback. They asked which players had proved them right or wrong. I gave more credit to what made it into the lineup of the manager who paid for the pick. We agreed on eight of 26 calls. Before anyone tries to make that a score for man versus machine, consider what happened when we started arguing about a guy who went on IR.
We agreed on 8 of 26 calls.
The interesting part is why the other 18 went different ways.
These are different definitions of draft value, not an accuracy contest. Tap any round to see the argument.
Jump to the round-by-round grades ↓ Listen to Jason & Connor ↗
Connor had a point about Achane
De’Von Achane gave Ricky 24.6 points in three starts. That’s my worst return in Round 2, and the injury is a big reason why. Connor explicitly passed over Achane because getting hurt is bad luck. He picked his own Jeremiyah Love, who gave him 53.4 in six starts. His gripe was with the production even before the injury that landed Love on IR. I buy the distinction. I’m grading what happened, not handing out demerits for failing to predict it.
That same distinction makes Round 5 more interesting. Jason picked Quinshon Judkins because he didn’t like what Judkins was doing with the work he was getting. Fair. But Rick Sr. still got 86.6 points in seven starts. Taylor got 12.8 from Jadarian Price, who was already out of his lineup before an IR stretch. I have Price lower, but “couldn’t use him” and “shouldn’t have drafted him” are very different charges.
How much of a bad return was bad luck?
Two second-round backs, two different conversations about what went wrong.

Achane: Ricky got three starts before the injury-driven absence.

Love: Connor got six starts, but little edge over the weekly RB benchmark.
Bars start at zero and share a 60-point scale within this chart. Only actual lineup points count; no bench totals or hypothetical injury production.
The Pickens pick has a better receipt than its reputation
Jason’s Round 3 call was a bet on where things were going. He was worried about Pickens getting less work and had Etienne as his runner-up. If you’re asking who might hurt you from here, the role is worth watching. But the receipt says Pickens gave Maconi 68.5 points in five starts and Poles another 35.8 after changing teams. Etienne gave Poles 30.9 in three starts before injuries took him out of the picture. I wouldn’t call Pickens the worst pick based on what he actually delivered.
The smaller version of this argument is Round 4. Jason picked Kyren Williams. I picked D’Andre Swift. Swift won by 0.7 points in eight starts, which is not a margin I’d want to defend on a witness stand. If you buy Jason’s argument about Kyren’s workload holding up, go ahead and take Kyren.
Pickens’ points didn’t disappear when he changed teams.
The podcast’s concern was what comes next. This review is grading the return already delivered.

68.5 for Maconi, then 35.8 for Poles.

30.9 for Poles; missed time drives much of the shortfall.
Bars start at zero and share a 120-point scale within this chart. Only actual lineup points count; no bench totals or hypothetical injury production.
The last two rounds belong to whoever kept the player
My Round 12 pick was Denzel Boston. He gave Glen five starts and 42.8 points. The argument for Boston isn’t that he was a better football player than Love. It’s that Glen actually got to use his pick. Same deal in Round 13: Will got an 18.02-point spot start out of Jared Goff, while Coker never started for Rick Sr. Then Poles and Maconi got 45.6 starting points out of Coker between them.
If we’re giving out a scouting award, give Connor the Love call and Jason the Coker call. They found the right players to talk about. But it’s also worth asking who got paid. Once the league gets to Round 13, there’s no shame in winning the scouting award. It just doesn’t count in the standings.
Finding the player and keeping the points are two different wins.
Love and Coker helped someone. Boston and Goff helped the manager who drafted them.

Taylor drafted him. Poles got the four starts.

Five starts for Glen, the original drafter.

Rick Sr. drafted him. Poles and Maconi got the starts.

One spot start, banked by Will.
Bars start at zero and share a 90-point scale within this chart. Only actual lineup points count; no bench totals or hypothetical injury production.
For all the arguing, the board still agrees on how Buttons kept a first-round miss from swallowing his draft. Barkley gave him 35.4 starting points. Walker and Higgins gave him 299.7 between them. All three of us chose the same players in those spots. The fact that your first pick hurt doesn’t mean the rest of your draft has to.
The complete board · Through Week 8
Round by round
Pick numbers are overall. The manager under each graded player drafted him, and the points and starts are what that manager got. The bottom lists run from worst return upward. In a strong round, making the bottom three doesn’t mean a player was a bust.
Compare all 26 podcast and Notebook calls
| Round | Podcast best | Notebook best | Podcast worst | Notebook worst |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Jahmyr GibbsConnor | Jaxon Smith-Njigba | Saquon BarkleyJason | Saquon BarkleyAgreed |
| 2 | Kenneth Walker IIIJason | Kenneth Walker IIIAgreed | Jeremiyah LoveConnor | De'Von Achane |
| 3 | Trey McBrideConnor | Trey McBrideAgreed | George PickensJason | Travis Etienne Jr. |
| 4 | Kyren WilliamsJason | D'Andre Swift | Ladd McConkeyConnor | Rome Odunze |
| 5 | Tee HigginsConnor | Tee HigginsAgreed | Quinshon JudkinsJason | Jadarian Price |
| 6 | Jaylen WarrenJason | Christian Watson | Marvin Harrison Jr.Connor | Marvin Harrison Jr.Agreed |
| 7 | Rhamondre StevensonConnor | Michael Wilson | Brian Thomas Jr.Jason | Jonathon Brooks |
| 8 | Matthew GoldenJason | Matthew GoldenAgreed | Quentin JohnstonConnor | Kyle Pitts Sr. |
| 9 | Isaiah LikelyConnor | Chuba Hubbard | Jordan AddisonJason | De'Zhaun Stribling |
| 10 | Brock PurdyJason | Brock PurdyAgreed | Kyler MurrayConnor | Jake Ferguson |
| 11 | Woody MarksJason · tentative | Aaron Jones Sr. | Travis HunterConnor | Travis HunterAgreed |
| 12 | Jordan LoveConnor | Denzel Boston | Cyrus AllenJason | Jalen McMillan |
| 13 | Jalen CokerJason | Jared Goff | Baker MayfieldConnor | Isiah Pacheco |
How the grades work
The original ESPN board has 156 picks across 13 rounds. I used actual Weeks 1–8 box scores from the Nov. 6 ESPN sync (11:19 a.m. Pacific). Week 9 was incomplete in that sync and is excluded. I checked the player scoring against both team totals in all 48 completed matchups.
For each start, I compared the player’s score to the lower-quartile score among EUXC starters at the same position that week, then added those differences. That’s a positional comparison, not an estimate of a waiver replacement or of points the manager could have guaranteed. I used that alongside actual starts and points to order the best returns. The bottom three are editorial calls: I weighed empty picks, repeated weak starts and points the original drafter never got. In Round 13, later lineup contribution breaks the tie among otherwise unused finds.
Injury labels reflect ESPN roster designations captured during or immediately after the grading window. I didn’t give hypothetical points for games a player missed. An injury-driven miss is a bad result, not necessarily a bad decision. Points from another manager’s lineup are identified separately, not credited to the original team.
Podcast calls and timestamps come from the supplied recording of EUXC 20.12: Special Draft Lookback. Jason and Connor’s comments are their opinions at recording time, not verified injury updates or our projections.
Round 1
All rounds ↑Gibbs beat Smith-Njigba per start, 27.97 to 27.50. I take the extra start, the bigger edge at WR and the fact that Glen didn’t have to draft first to get him.
Three best picks
-
Jaxon Smith-Njigba219.96 pts · 8 startsMost starting points of any pick in the draft, and the biggest edge in this round over a lower-end starter at his position.
-
Jahmyr Gibbs195.8 pts · 7 startsBest per-start scoring in the round. A No. 1 pick that played like one, with one fewer start than Smith-Njigba.
-
CeeDee Lamb168.3 pts · 8 startsEight starts and the third-best position-adjusted return of the round. Ricky got a genuine anchor at No. 11.
Three worst returns
-
Saquon Barkley35.4 pts · 5 startsMissed timeFour of his five starts stayed at nine points or less. The missed time matters, but it doesn’t account for the quiet games when he was in the lineup.
-
Chase Brown90.9 pts · 7 startsSeven starts gave Poles more to work with than Barkley gave Buttons, but he was the only other first-rounder under 100 starting points.
-
James Cook III131.7 pts · 7 startsThis is the bottom of a strong round, not a bust. Among the remaining first-rounders, Cook had the smallest edge over the weekly position benchmark.
Round 2
All rounds ↑Walker is an easy place to agree. Our disagreement is what to do with Achane’s injury: it wrecked the return, but Connor doesn’t hold it against the original decision.
Three best picks
-
Kenneth Walker III160.1 pts · 7 startsFive starts over 20 points and the round’s best advantage over a lower-end starter. He gave Buttons the RB production missing from Round 1.
-
Brock Bowers123.7 pts · 6 startsTwo fewer starts than a full eight-week slate, yet a 97.3-point edge over the weekly TE benchmark in the six games Jason used him.
-
Josh Allen187.82 pts · 7 startsThe round’s raw scoring leader. He lands third because QBs score more to begin with, so his advantage over a lower-end starter was smaller than Walker’s or Bowers’.
Three worst returns
-
De'Von Achane24.6 pts · 3 startsInjury-drivenRicky got three starts before Achane disappeared from his lineup and was listed on IR. That makes it the worst return for me, not the least defensible pick.
-
A.J. Brown19.1 pts · 3 startsInjury and outputLowest raw starting return in the round. An IR stretch cut into availability, and none of his three starts reached eight points.
-
Jeremiyah Love53.4 pts · 6 startsInjury and outputSix starts left him only 5.4 points above the weekly low-end RB benchmark. Injury made the return worse, but there was already a production gap.
Round 3
All rounds ↑McBride is the consensus pick. Pickens lands outside my bottom three because the points were real, even if Jason’s concern about what comes next proves right.
Three best picks
-
Trey McBride150.4 pts · 8 startsEight double-digit starts at TE and a 111.3-point positional edge. That’s the biggest advantage any pick delivered in this round.
-
Chris Olave124.6 pts · 7 startsA seven-start regular for Jason. His position-adjusted return beat the round’s other receivers, including Nabers and Flowers.
-
Malik Nabers120.5 pts · 7 startsNearly matched Olave and gave Rick Sr. 120.5 points. The position-adjusted gap between the two was just 4.1 points.
Three worst returns
-
Travis Etienne Jr.30.9 pts · 3 startsInjury-drivenPoles got three starts, then no more through Week 8. ESPN listed him on IR during the stretch. The missing weeks drive this grade.
-
Breece Hall42.5 pts · 3 startsInjury-drivenMore points than Etienne in the same number of starts, but Wells still got no starts after Week 3 while Hall carried injury designations.
-
Rashee Rice56.3 pts · 5 startsInjury and outputFive starts made him more usable than Hall or Etienne, but Will got only 56.3 points. ESPN listed Rice out during part of that stretch.
Round 4
All rounds ↑Swift and Kyren are essentially tied. On the other side, I ranked Odunze lower than McConkey because Jason got less out of more starts.
Three best picks
-
D'Andre Swift150.7 pts · 8 startsEight starts for Maconi and the narrowest win on this board: seven-tenths of a point over Kyren.
-
Kyren Williams150 pts · 8 startsEight starts and 150 points. Jason preferred the security of his workload. It’s a reasonable tiebreaker if you’re grading the pick going forward.
-
Tetairoa McMillan108.9 pts · 7 startsSeven starts gave Poles steady use and a 65.9-point edge at WR, just enough to beat Davante Adams for the last spot.
Three worst returns
-
Rome Odunze37.3 pts · 5 startsFive starts never yielded more than 10.9 in a week. Another 35.5 came outside Jason’s starting lineup, so this grade is partly about which weeks he got.
-
Ladd McConkey42.4 pts · 4 startsV banked 42.4 from four starts. Connor expected dependable PPR volume, and there wasn’t enough of it to make McConkey a regular.
-
DJ Moore52.9 pts · 7 startsInjury and outputSeven starts look useful until you see they included two zeros and a negative. There was an OUT tag in the stretch, but the other starts didn’t make up the difference.
Round 5
All rounds ↑Connor switched from Burden to Higgins. Jason liked Washington earlier in the year, so we ended up discussing the same three receivers. The fight is over Judkins, not the top of the round.
Three best picks
-
Tee Higgins139.6 pts · 7 startsFour games above 20 in seven starts. Week 8’s 37.5 was the exclamation point, not the whole argument.
-
Luther Burden III115.6 pts · 8 startsStarted every week for V and delivered 115.6. Connor’s first instinct was defensible even after Higgins pulled ahead.
-
Parker Washington95.5 pts · 7 startsSeven starts and a 52.9-point edge over the low-end WR benchmark. A good stretch early became a useful season-long return through the cutoff.
Three worst returns
-
Jadarian Price12.8 pts · 2 startsInjury and outputTwo starts for 12.8, then none after Week 2. Price went on IR later; the injury explains some of the missing return, not those first two results.
-
Terry McLaurin46 pts · 6 startsInjury and outputWill used him six times and got 46 points. The synced history shows later OUT and IR tags, and he was off Will’s roster by the Nov. 6 sync.
-
Lamar Jackson79.08 pts · 5 startsInjury and outputOnly five starts and a modest edge over the QB benchmark. Missed time mattered, and the Nov. 6 sync listed him on IR. This is a return grade, not a talent grade.
Round 6
All rounds ↑Jason favored the scarcity of a back like Warren. I have Watson first because both started eight times and Watson gave V the larger edge at his position.
Three best picks
-
Christian Watson146.8 pts · 8 startsEight starts, 146.8 points and the round’s best position-adjusted return. He supplied 98.5 more than the weekly low-end WR benchmark.
-
Jaylen Warren140.8 pts · 8 startsEight starts and 140.8 points at RB. For a team that needed reliable backfield work, it’s easy to see why Jason picked his own guy.
-
Joe Burrow169.6 pts · 7 startsThe round’s highest raw point total in seven starts. Adjusting for the higher QB scoring baseline puts Burrow third.
Three worst returns
-
Marvin Harrison Jr.4.3 pts · 1 startOne 4.3-point start for Poles before he changed teams. A later injury tag doesn’t explain why the original pick yielded so little.
-
TreVeyon Henderson4.8 pts · 1 startInjury and outputMaconi banked 4.8 points from one start. Later injury designations limited the chance to recover, but most of the recorded points were outside the lineup.
-
Courtland Sutton38.8 pts · 7 startsSeven starts for 38.8 points. Unlike a stash that never saw the field, Sutton was in Wells’ lineup often enough for the weak returns to add up.
Round 7
All rounds ↑Connor liked Stevenson’s consistency and role. Through Week 8, Wilson had more total starting points and a bigger position-adjusted edge, and I had Thomas one spot away from Jason’s call.
Three best picks
-
Michael Wilson108.68 pts · 8 startsStarted all eight weeks, twice topping 25. His edge over the WR benchmark was bigger than any RB or TE managed in this round.
-
Harold Fannin Jr.90.1 pts · 8 startsEight starts made Fannin a dependable way for Glen to fill TE. The positional edge matters more here than his lower raw total.
-
Tony Pollard95.4 pts · 6 startsGave Wells 95.4 in six starts and had another 21.1 outside the lineup. Stevenson was used more often, but Pollard produced more above the RB benchmark.
Three worst returns
-
Jonathon Brooks0 pts · 0 startsInjury-drivenZero starts for Ricky. An IR stretch explains much of the missing return; a seventh-round bet that didn’t pay, not a verdict on the player.
-
Brian Thomas Jr.15.8 pts · 3 starts15.8 points in three starts for Buttons, below the weekly low-end WR benchmark in aggregate. Jason’s case for him as the biggest underperformer is strong.
-
Michael Pittman Jr.8.8 pts · 1 startInjury-drivenOne 8.8-point start before an IR stretch. Rick Sr. got little return, but health is part of the explanation.
Round 8
All rounds ↑Golden wins both boards. Connor called out a player who never helped Will’s lineup; I put Pitts below him because Taylor repeatedly started him and got the wrong weeks.
Three best picks
-
Matthew Golden131.5 pts · 8 startsStarted all eight weeks and reached 20 four times. Jason got regular WR production at a point in the draft where it gets scarce.
-
George Kittle101.3 pts · 6 startsSix starts for 101.3. Kittle came within 5.3 points of Golden after accounting for what a low-end starter scores at each position.
-
Stefon Diggs65.8 pts · 5 starts65.8 points from five starts, with a stronger position-adjusted return than the QBs here. OUT tags in the middle of the stretch cut into Maconi’s use.
Three worst returns
-
Kyle Pitts Sr.19.8 pts · 5 startsTaylor got 19.8 in five starts while 45.9 sat outside the lineup. Not a claim Pitts had no good weeks; the useful weeks didn’t line up with the starts.
-
Quentin Johnston0 pts · 0 startsInjury and outputNo starts for Will and 18.1 points outside the lineup. The injury tags mattered, but the pick wasn’t producing starting value before them either.
-
Alec Pierce0 pts · 0 startsInjury-drivenNo starts and just 12.2 points in the tracked box scores. An early IR stretch explains why Wells never got a chance to use the pick.
Round 9
All rounds ↑Connor took Likely; Jason nominated Hubbard as the other steal. I have Hubbard by just 4.7 points over the positional benchmark. Jason’s Addison call was about unmet expectations; my bottom three each gave their drafters zero starts.
Three best picks
-
Chuba Hubbard133 pts · 7 startsSeven starts, all in double digits. Will got 133 points and a small position-adjusted win over Likely.
-
Isaiah Likely98.9 pts · 6 starts98.9 points in six starts at TE. Connor’s pick was close on positional value and looks even better if you prize a weekly TE edge.
-
Travis Kelce82 pts · 7 startsSeven starts and 82 points. Having Kittle around didn’t prevent Kelce from delivering for Rick Sr. when he used him.
Three worst returns
-
De'Zhaun Stribling0 pts · 0 startsInjury-drivenZero starts, no points in his recorded roster appearances and an early IR designation. The result is clear; how much was predictable is not.
-
Jayden Reed0 pts · 0 startsInjury-drivenNo starts and only 6.4 observed points. An IR stretch took away most of the chance to turn the pick into WR depth.
-
Jordan Mason0 pts · 0 startsInjury-drivenNo starts for Buttons through the cutoff. Mason did score 20.7 outside the lineup and was still held; the IR stretch makes this a low return so far, not a write-off.
Round 10
All rounds ↑Purdy is a clean agreement. Connor saw Murray as a disappointment relative to expectations. I have him ahead of the bottom three because he returned a start for Maconi and still contributed after moving teams.
Three best picks
-
Brock Purdy146.02 pts · 7 startsGlen got 146.02 points over seven starts without spending an early pick on QB. The best position-adjusted return of the round, too.
-
Juwan Johnson65.8 pts · 6 startsSix starts and 65.8 points for Ricky, only 3.8 points behind Purdy by the position-adjusted measure.
-
Dalton Kincaid28 pts · 3 startsOnly three starts, but the 28 points V banked carried a better positional edge than the round’s other alternatives.
Three worst returns
-
Jake Ferguson21.6 pts · 5 startsFive starts, never double digits, and his biggest week came outside Taylor’s lineup. That’s the least useful return among the players asked to do regular work here.
-
Bo Nix0 pts · 0 startsNo starts for Rick Sr., but 26.18 points in Jason’s lineup. Like Love later on the board, he was a better player find than his return to the original drafter.
-
Keaton Mitchell4.9 pts · 1 startJason got one 4.9-point start. The rest of his observed production never reached Jason’s starting lineup.
Round 11
All rounds ↑Jason picked Marks without much conviction. Connor floated Kyle Monangai. I take the six weeks Wells actually got out of Jones, and agree with Connor on Hunter.
Three best picks
-
Aaron Jones Sr.69.8 pts · 6 starts69.8 in six starts. Kamara had a slightly bigger positional edge in two starts, but six weeks of RB cover win the tiebreak here.
-
Alvin Kamara37.7 pts · 2 starts37.7 in just two starts, good for the largest positional edge of the round. Buttons got two useful weeks rather than a regular.
-
Woody Marks19.2 pts · 2 startsTwo starts for V and 43.3 more points outside the lineup. There’s a case for his underlying production; I have him third on what V banked.
Three worst returns
-
Travis Hunter0 pts · 0 startsZero starts and 2.1 points in the one recorded roster week. Connor distinguished a good football player from a useful fantasy receiver.
-
Jordyn Tyson0 pts · 0 startsInjury-drivenZero starts and zero points in the tracked box scores. Tyson spent much of the window listed on IR. This is an unfulfilled stash, not a scouting verdict.
-
Chris Rodriguez Jr.0 pts · 0 startsNo starts for Jason and just 3.6 outside his lineup before the player moved on. A low-cost dart that never became a lineup option.
Round 12
All rounds ↑Connor’s Love call makes more sense if you follow the player. My board follows the original pick: Taylor banked zero from Love, while Glen used Boston five times.
Three best picks
-
Denzel Boston42.8 pts · 5 startsFive starts and 42.8 points in Glen’s lineup. Boston had the best position-adjusted original-team return in the round.
-
Tyler Shough53.56 pts · 3 startsRicky got 53.56 from three starts. Shough’s edge over the QB benchmark was second in the round, and he gave Ricky an actual spot-start option.
-
Patrick Mahomes32.94 pts · 2 startsTwo starts earned Poles 32.94 and a small positive QB edge. Stafford got more starts and more raw points for Connor, but less edge above the weekly QB benchmark.
Three worst returns
-
Jalen McMillan0 pts · 0 startsInjury-drivenNo starts and zero points in the tracked box scores. ESPN listed him on IR, so the roster return was poor without making this a draft-day mistake.
-
Cyrus Allen0 pts · 0 startsNo starts and 4.7 points outside Maconi’s lineup. Jason’s pick is a fair call in a round with several players who barely made a mark.
-
Zach Charbonnet0 pts · 0 startsInjury-drivenNo starts and 5.9 points outside the lineup. Repeated OUT designations narrowed the window for Jason’s stash to pay off.
Round 13
All rounds ↑Goff was the only pick in the round to beat the positional benchmark for his original team. Once that question is settled, Coker and Tucker get the next two spots for the starting points they delivered elsewhere.
Three best picks
-
Jared Goff18.02 pts · 1 startWill got one 18.02-point spot start. That’s not much, but it was the strongest useful starting return that stayed with the original drafter.
-
Jalen Coker0 pts · 0 startsNo starts for Rick Sr.; 45.6 points in five starts for Poles and Maconi. Jason’s best-player call is persuasive even though the original drafter didn’t cash in.
-
Tre Tucker0 pts · 0 startsNo starts for Glen, then 21.3 starting points for V. He gets the third spot for what he became after the pick, not for what Glen got out of it.
Three worst returns
-
Isiah Pacheco0 pts · 0 startsInjury-drivenNo starts and zero points in six tracked roster weeks. An IR stretch makes the outcome unlucky; it’s still the thinnest return on the board.
-
Mack Hollins0 pts · 0 startsInjury-drivenTaylor got no starts, and Hollins was on Connor’s IR by the Nov. 6 sync. There’s not enough recorded usage to judge the talent bet.
-
Ja'Kobi Lane0 pts · 0 startsInjury and outputAn IR stretch and no starts for Poles. Lane did give Jason 2.3 points in one start, a bit more of a footprint than the other two.