Preseason

Three teams share the strongest opening case

The draft left three teams almost level at the top: Glen, David, and Will each grade at 85 before a game has been played. Glen's receiver-heavy starting group wins the tiebreaker, while David has the deepest bench and Will the strongest projected starters. These are opening positions, not predictions of who will finish first.

Retrospective edition prepared October 6 using the completed August draft and a September 3 projection snapshot. No regular-season results or later roster moves are included.

1—
Glen's Team logo

Glen's Team

Glen Cornell

A receiver-first route to No. 1

Glen opened with Jaxon Smith-Njigba, Drake London, and Zay Flowers in three of the first four rounds, a clear bet that the league's two FLEX spots would reward strong receiver depth. Kyren Williams and Josh Jacobs arrived later to give the lineup a workable backfield without sacrificing that original plan. On the September 3 projections, this is one of the league's strongest starting groups.

The narrow lead over David and Will should not be mistaken for separation. Glen ranks fifth in usable bench depth, so the starting lineup is doing most of the work in this first estimate. If the receivers deliver, this construction can make opponents chase points across multiple slots. If an early RB choice disappoints, the margin behind the starters is less imposing than the No. 1 rank suggests.

2—
Davids Team logo

Davids Team

David Wells

The best safety net in the draft

David assembled a recognizable core without concentrating every early pick at one position: Amon-Ra St. Brown, Derrick Henry, Breece Hall, and Davante Adams. Jayden Daniels followed in the fifth round. The projected starting lineup is strong enough to keep this team in the top group, and the first-ranked bench is what makes the preseason case distinctive.

Depth matters in a long season, but this is still a forecast built before anyone has produced an actual point. Some of the reserve value may become trade leverage; some may simply cover injuries or bye weeks. David's immediate challenge is choosing the right combination each week rather than finding another big name. Among teams with comparable opening scores, this roster has the most obvious protection against a single miss.

3—
Rotten Meat logo

Rotten Meat

Will Bertram

The strongest starters, by a hair

Will started the entire draft with Jahmyr Gibbs, then paired Josh Allen and Rashee Rice at the second turn. Terry McLaurin, Sam LaPorta, and Chuba Hubbard filled in a roster that projects to have the strongest starting lineup in the league on this snapshot. The top-end case is straightforward: Gibbs and Allen can create positional advantages before the rest of the lineup needs to do anything unusual.

The tradeoff is a ninth-ranked bench. That does not make the opening team weak, but it means an absence or role change could be harder to absorb than it would be for David. Glen, David, and Will all carry an 85 power score into the season; tiebreakers sort them, not a meaningful gulf in expected strength. Will looks built to win with the first-choice lineup.

4—
OLD MAN logo

OLD MAN

Rick Myers

A formidable front line with an unusual finish

Rick Sr. collected Ja'Marr Chase, Nico Collins, and Malik Nabers in the first three rounds, then added Quinshon Judkins and David Montgomery. That gives OLD MAN several ways to fill two receiver slots and both FLEX positions. The preseason model likes the starting talent, even if it places this roster a step behind the three-team lead group.

The late draft took a more specialized turn. George Kittle and Travis Kelce both joined after a roster that already had Drake Maye, creating multiple alternatives at positions with only one starting slot. There can be matchup value in that, but two tight ends cannot both solve a thin RB or WR week. The second-ranked bench suggests there is still useful material here; the question is how much of it can actually enter a weekly lineup.

5—
Skatteboogie Nights logo

Skatteboogie Nights

John Maconi

A solid center, with choices to make

John began with Jonathan Taylor and A.J. Brown, then reinforced the receiving group with George Pickens. D'Andre Swift, Cam Skattebo, and TreVeyon Henderson give Skatteboogie Nights several backfield paths, while Dak Prescott arrived later than most of the premium-position investment. It is a balanced draft by position, and the initial model places the projected starters in the league's upper half.

That balance is less pronounced on the bench, which opens the season ranked tenth in usable value. The larger opportunity is in getting the right FLEX arrangement from the backs and receivers John already has. This team does not need every mid-round player to break out, but it may need one of them to become a reliable weekly choice to close the gap on the four teams above it.

6—
Shough Depot logo

Shough Depot

Taylor Zorski

Two backs set the identity

Taylor's first two picks, Christian McCaffrey and Ashton Jeanty, make the team's direction unmistakable. DeVonta Smith and Jameson Williams followed to keep the receiver side credible, and Jalen Hurts in the sixth round adds a potential weekly edge at quarterback. The September projections see an above-average starting lineup, though not one in the top cluster.

The third-ranked bench gives this roster more cover than its sixth-place power ranking might suggest. Yet the concentration of early value at RB cuts both ways: a healthy, productive backfield would let Taylor dictate FLEX choices, while trouble at that spot would force later picks to carry more weight. For now, Shough Depot looks like a team with a clear bet and enough alternatives to test it.

7—
Team Name logo

Team Name

Connor O'Brian

A superstar anchor, then several forks

Connor landed Bijan Robinson at No. 2 overall and used his next two picks on Jeremiyah Love and Trey McBride. The first choice gives the roster a powerful RB anchor, while McBride can separate at tight end. Carnell Tate, Mike Evans, and DJ Moore create multiple possible receiver combinations, but the model is less convinced by the total projected starting eight than by the headline names.

This is a middle-of-the-pack preseason grade, not a verdict on Connor's first year in the league. With the eighth-ranked bench and several important FLEX decisions ahead, there is room for the roster to outperform its initial point estimate if the receiver group resolves favorably. There is also no prior league drafting profile to apply to Connor; this ranking is about the players taken, not an inferred manager tendency.

8—
Call Me Mayebe logo

Call Me Mayebe

Eric Lewandowski

A balanced draft, looking for an edge

Eric paired Chase Brown and Justin Jefferson at the first turn, then added Travis Etienne Jr. and Tetairoa McMillan at the next. Tyler Warren and Marvin Harrison Jr. deepen the mix before Justin Herbert enters at quarterback. There is no glaring positional omission; Call Me Mayebe has plausible starters across the lineup.

What the model does not yet see is enough separating value to move the team into the upper half. The projected starters rank below several similarly balanced rosters, and the sixth-ranked bench is useful without being a major advantage. That makes individual role growth more important here than on teams whose first eight players already project to carry them. The season can change that assessment quickly, but the preseason evidence remains measured.

9—
Sun God and Squad logo

Sun God and Squad

Justin Veldhuis

Depth before certainty

Justin opened with James Cook III and Omarion Hampton, then assembled a large receiver group led by Emeka Egbuka and Ladd McConkey. Dalton Kincaid and Tucker Kraft provide tight-end options, with Caleb Williams arriving at quarterback in the eighth round. The fourth-ranked bench is a genuine asset in the opening projection.

The problem is nearer the top of the lineup. Sun God and Squad's projected starters sit close to the bottom of the league, so the reserve strength may represent alternatives rather than a ready-made eight that can match the leaders. If one of the young receivers claims a larger role, or if Justin turns bench surplus into a stronger weekly starter, this ninth-place forecast could age quickly. Before games begin, those are possibilities rather than results.

10—
Listen to the Podcast logo

Listen to the Podcast

Jason Mac

Big names, narrow support

Jason came away with Puka Nacua, Brock Bowers, Chris Olave, and Lamar Jackson, a strong set of players at three different positions. Bowers in particular can create a weekly tight-end advantage. The first impression is stronger than the aggregate score, because the model is measuring an entire starting lineup and the depth behind it, not just the recognizable top four.

Listen to the Podcast begins with the twelfth-ranked bench. Jaylen Warren and Blake Corum give the running back group possibilities, but the opening projections do not yet treat them as enough to lift the whole roster. If the early stars perform near their ceilings, Jason can look better than tenth almost immediately. If one is unavailable, there is less room to patch the lineup than the draft-day names suggest.

11—
Touchdown My Pants logo

Touchdown My Pants

Sean Martyn

The backs carry the opening case

Sean secured Saquon Barkley and Kenneth Walker III at picks 10 and 15, then added Garrett Wilson, Colston Loveland, and Tee Higgins. There is enough talent here to imagine a stronger finish than eleventh, especially if the running backs produce at their higher-end outcomes. Joe Burrow gives the roster a familiar quarterback foundation.

The September projection snapshot is more cautious about the full starting group, and the bench ranks eleventh. A top-heavy RB start can be powerful in this format, but it leaves less margin if the receivers do not fill both base slots and the FLEX positions consistently. For now, Touchdown My Pants has a path to compete rather than a proven preseason edge over most of the league.

12—
The Place That Makes Me Happy logo

The Place That Makes Me Happy

Ricky Myers

The model starts skeptical

Ricky chose CeeDee Lamb and De'Von Achane at the first turn, then Javonte Williams and Jaylen Waddle at the next. That is a recognizable opening core, and the later selections of Parker Washington, Wan'Dale Robinson, and Trevor Lawrence give the roster several ways to fill out a lineup. Last place here does not mean the roster lacks good players.

It means that, against eleven other completed rosters on the September 3 forecast, this combination supplies the least projected starter value. The seventh-ranked bench does not offset that gap. Ricky could outrun the estimate if the middle-round receivers earn larger roles or the backs supply more than their median projections. Preseason rankings are particularly uncertain for this kind of roster: most of the case for improvement is in outcomes that have not happened yet.

Preseason scores compare projected starters and useful bench depth using the September 3 FantasyPros snapshot and the completed draft. They include no game results or manager grade and are not championship probabilities.