Week 5

Will pulls ahead as Jason joins the contenders

Will turns a narrow lead into a convincing hold on No. 1, while Jason's 169.6-point eruption reshuffles the contenders behind him. Ricky remains unbeaten in head-to-head play but finally misses a victory point, and the middle of the league gets tighter as David climbs. Five weeks in, the standings and the strongest rosters are telling slightly different stories.

1—
Chuba Libre logo

Chuba Libre

Will Bertram

Week 5 resultBeat John 156.9–115.9

The favorite opens some daylight

Last week, Will held first place by a fraction. This week, he made the argument considerably easier. A 156.9–115.9 win over Maconi took him to 9-1, with Josh Allen, Jahmyr Gibbs, and Bucky Irving supplying 99.7 points before the rest of the lineup was counted. Even a zero in one receiver slot could not make this close. It was the kind of performance that turns a strong roster on paper into an uncomfortable opponent in practice.

Will now leads both the projected starting-lineup and bench rankings. That matters more than the round-number power score: 100 is a relative rating within this league, not a perfect team or a title guarantee. Glen still has the slightly higher season scoring total, but Will has more projected cover behind his starters and four scoring victory points alongside five matchup wins. Receiver consistency remains the opening for everyone chasing him. The rest of the roster is doing a remarkable job of making that opening look small.

2—
Drake and Josh logo

Drake and Josh

Glen Cornell

Week 5 resultBeat Connor 118.6–97.4

A quieter win still pays twice

Glen did not need another 145-point week to beat Connor. Seven of his eight starters reached double figures in the 118.6–97.4 win, a useful reminder that this offense has more than one way to get there. Jaxon Smith-Njigba led with 22.8, but nobody had to drag the rest of the lineup across the finish line. The victory point was less comfortable: Glen claimed the final scoring spot by just 2.62 points over Maconi, turning a solid Sunday into a two-point week.

At 7-3, Glen still leads the league in cumulative starter scoring, albeit by only 5.94 points over Will. The projected starters remain second, which keeps him comfortably in the top tier even as Will creates separation. The thinner ninth-ranked bench is the reason not to treat that production as automatic. Fannin's 1.4 exposed a soft spot at tight end, while Smith-Njigba's ankle warrants a practice check after he finished Sunday's game. Neither changes the central story: this is a strong, balanced starting lineup with less insurance than the team above it.

3↑3
Listen to the Podcast logo

Listen to the Podcast

Jason Mac

Week 5 resultBeat Sean 169.6–97.2

The contender behind the microphone

Jason has something new to discuss on the podcast: the league's highest score of Week 5 and a three-place jump to third. His 169.6–97.2 win over Sean was not simply Puka Nacua having a huge day. Jaylen Warren nearly matched Puka's 37.7 with 36.8 of his own, Brock Bowers added 23, and Aaron Rodgers supplied 22 in the starting quarterback slot. A roster that spent September waiting for its premium pieces to come together has now produced consecutive convincing wins.

The refreshed outlook supports the climb, placing Jason's projected starters third rather than asking one explosive result to carry the whole case. Warren is especially important to the shape of this team: reliable RB production would ease the pressure on the expensive pass-catching core. His coach's latest description of him as a featured player is encouraging, though 36-point Sundays should not become the expectation. At 6-4 with a middle-of-the-pack bench, Jason has not erased the gap to Will and Glen. He has made himself the most credible new challenger.

4↓1
The Disrespect Tour logo

The Disrespect Tour

Connor O'Brian

Week 5 resultLost to Glen 118.6–97.4

The talent is ahead of the results

Connor's fourth-place ranking alongside a 4-6 record is the clearest bet on unrealized roster strength near the top. Matthew Stafford, Mike Evans, and Trey McBride combined for 75.2 in the loss to Glen. The other five starters combined for just 22.2. That is an exceptionally uneven way to build a 97.4-point week, and it explains why a team with several excellent building blocks can still struggle to put a complete lineup on the scoreboard.

Unlike last week's loss, this one was not hiding a winning score on the bench. The reserves would not have bridged the 21.1-point gap, so blaming another lineup decision would miss the point. Connor's season-long manager grade remains a concern, but the more immediate requirement is production from the supporting slots. The fourth-ranked bench and a competitive forward outlook preserve his place here, narrowly ahead of David. There is still enough talent for a rebound; the ranking will become harder to defend if that talent keeps arriving in isolated bursts.

5↑2
Third Years the Charm logo

Third Years the Charm

David Wells

Week 5 resultBeat Rick Sr. 131.8–121.2

Back to even, looking up

David's 131.8–121.2 win over Rick Sr. restored a 5-5 record and supplied something the previous edition was missing: a productive Jayden Daniels in the starting lineup. Daniels's 32.3 was the centerpiece, but Davante Adams and Derrick Henry both cleared 20, and Aaron Jones added 18.7. This was a genuinely strong score against an opponent who also played well, not a standings improvement built on catching somebody else's collapse.

David rises two places to fifth, almost level with Connor, and now carries the fourth-best projected starting group. His 95% manager grade is relevant here because it suggests the points the roster has offered are largely reaching the lineup. There is less obvious value to recover through simple selection changes than there is for some rivals. The sixth-ranked bench provides a reasonable cushion, but the bigger opportunity is sustaining this fuller-strength version of the starters. If Week 5 becomes representative rather than exceptional, the top four is within reach.

6↓2
Revival logo

Revival

Ricky Myers

Week 5 resultBeat Taylor 105.9–100.2

Still unbeaten, no longer unblemished

Nobody has beaten Ricky head-to-head. Taylor came close, but Parker Washington's 30.4 and Braelon Allen's 18.6 helped preserve a 105.9–100.2 win on a day when CeeDee Lamb and Jaylen Waddle combined for only 7.7. The first blemish came from the other contest: Ricky finished outside the top six in scoring, dropping the combined record to 9-1. That distinction matters. He won the matchup he was given, but the league-wide comparison was less flattering.

Dropping from fourth to sixth while winning will understandably invite an objection. The reason is the refreshed outlook, which puts Ricky's projected starters near the lower end of the league, while Jason and David strengthened their cases. An eighth-ranked bench also offers less protection than last week's edition suggested. None of that cancels five straight matchup wins or the points already banked. It means the model expects a tougher road ahead. Washington's emergence is a real counterargument, and repeating this kind of contribution would help close the gap between the standings and the forecast.

7↓2
Skatteboogie Nights logo

Skatteboogie Nights

John Maconi

Week 5 resultLost to Will 156.9–115.9

Better, but just below the line

Maconi's rebound from 80.8 to 115.9 points produced nothing in the standings. Will was far out of reach, and Glen took the last victory point by 2.62. That is a frustrating zero-point week because the lineup did offer two major successes: Isaiah Likely and George Pickens combined for 60.4. The problem was the spread around them. Three other starters finished below eight, leaving too much work for the two biggest performances to cover.

The second-ranked bench remains Maconi's best source of flexibility, but his projected starters now rank ninth. That imbalance is more interesting than the raw depth badge: useful reserves have value if they cover a weakness or can be consolidated into an improvement, not merely because they look good together on the bench. A.J. Brown could return to practice this week, according to the latest report, but that is not yet a confirmed return to games. Maconi falls to seventh because the lineup still needs more dependable contributions, not because all the good options have disappeared.

8—
OLD MAN logo

OLD MAN

Rick Myers

Week 5 resultLost to David 131.8–121.2

A loss with something to show for it

Rick Sr. got the quarterback decision right this time. Drake Maye's 39.5 joined Malik Nabers's 29.1 to drive a 121.2-point week, only for David to answer with 131.8. There was at least compensation: fifth in scoring earned Rick Sr. a victory point, moving him to 3-7 rather than leaving him empty-handed. This is exactly the sort of week the extra point is designed to recognize. Losing the matchup did not mean playing one of the league's worst games.

The concern is how concentrated the production remains. His two starting running backs combined for 9.1, and the latest report describes David Montgomery's groin injury as week-to-week. A bench tied for eleventh provides limited help behind an otherwise competitive top end. Maye and the receivers can keep Rick Sr. dangerous, but they are being asked to absorb too many weak spots at once. Eighth still feels like the dividing line between a roster capable of an impressive upset and one ready to string several strong weeks together.

9↑1
Cook-Out Runs logo

Cook-Out Runs

Justin Veldhuis

Week 5 resultBeat Eric 123.7–101.2

A response, not yet a turnaround

Justin nearly doubled last week's 64.1, beating Eric 123.7–101.2 and collecting both standings points. Christian Watson's 32.3 supplied the headline, but Jacoby Brissett's 25.3 and James Cook's 22.8 made this a broader recovery. A 4-6 record is far more manageable than another week drifting toward the bottom. It also gives Justin a result worth building on rather than another discussion about what his bench might theoretically accomplish.

The model moves him up one place, cautiously. The third-ranked bench is useful, but the projected starting group still ranks last, so this week's output is not yet the baseline the forecast expects. Watson's 109.4 points through five weeks provide a genuine reason to question some of that pessimism. At the same time, Hampton and Harvey combined for only 5.6 this week. A sustained climb needs fewer near-empty slots alongside the explosive ones. Justin has options; the next step is making the weekly lineup feel less dependent on a rescue performance.

10↓1
Trouble on Dookie Island logo

Trouble on Dookie Island

Sean Martyn

Week 5 resultLost to Jason 169.6–97.2

Outgunned, even with the right replacements

Sean found 31.5 points from MarShawn Lloyd and Ollie Gordon in the RB slots and still lost by 72.4. That says more about Jason's eruption than it does about those replacements. Joe Burrow and Garrett Wilson also delivered, but 97.2 was never going to survive the week's highest score. The tight-end and FLEX end of the lineup offered too little support, with Loveland and Sadiq combining for just 4.2.

There was no winning combination left unused on the bench. This was a limited lineup running into a much bigger week, not a failure to spot an obvious solution. Sean slips to tenth at 4-6, with a tenth-ranked bench and an outlook that still leaves room for improvement. The latest report says Barkley is hopeful for Week 6, not cleared, so that remains a possibility rather than something to pencil in. Getting more of the established core back would matter much more than trying to recreate Jason's extraordinary Sunday through marginal swaps.

11↑1
Starvin' Marvin logo

Starvin' Marvin

Eric Lewandowski

Week 5 resultLost to Justin 123.7–101.2

A better forecast than the scoreboard

Eric moves off the bottom despite losing 123.7–101.2 to Justin. The reason is not hidden in the result: his five-week scoring total remains last. It is in an improved forward outlook and a bench now ranked fifth. This week at least showed the value of having a usable quarterback alternative, with Jordan Love contributing 25.3 while Mahomes scored zero. Tyler Warren added 21.4 and Justin Jefferson 18.8, but the remaining starters could not turn that foundation into a top-six total.

At 3-7, Eric needs the healthier, more productive version of this roster to arrive soon. The running backs combined for just 18.3 across three starting slots, which shows how a few good receiving performances can still leave the whole team short. The projection model now sees a roughly middle-of-the-league outlook rather than an obvious last-place roster. That is a reason for cautious optimism, not a recovery already completed. Another week like this on the scoreboard would make the improved forecast feel increasingly theoretical.

12↓1
Potty Train logo

Potty Train

Taylor Zorski

Week 5 resultLost to Ricky 105.9–100.2

Close enough to hurt

Taylor was 5.76 points from handing Ricky his first matchup loss. Instead, the 105.9–100.2 result left him 2-8 and at the bottom of this week's rankings. There is a specific hindsight frustration: Kyle Pitts's 15.2 on the bench would have outscored starting tight end Jake Ferguson by 10.3, enough to flip the game. That does not make the choice obviously wrong before kickoff, but it does show how little separated a useful upset from another empty week.

The broader concern is that the updated projections offer little distance from the results so far. Taylor's starting outlook is eleventh and his bench is tied for eleventh. Jameson Williams's 18.7 and Darius Cooper's 15.1 helped make this competitive, but even a respectable day from McCaffrey did not lift the total into the top half. Taylor does not need to become the league's best team overnight. He needs enough dependable support to make these close matchups break his way, because there is less spare depth here to absorb another disappointing stretch.

Week 5 scorecard

Weekly scores and victory points

A top-six score earns a victory point. Winning a matchup earns a separate standings point, so a matchup loss can still produce a victory point.

The victory-point line118.56 pts

Glen took the last victory point, 2.62 ahead of John.

Lost the matchup, earned a victory point: Rick Sr.

Won the matchup, missed the victory point: Ricky

Week 5 scores and victory points, sorted by score
#TeamScoreMatchupVictory pointStandings pointsCutoff gap
1
JasonListen to the Podcast
169.60 Won +1 Earned +1 2 +53.66 clear
2
WillChuba Libre
156.90 Won +1 Earned +1 2 +40.96 clear
3
DavidThird Years the Charm
131.76 Won +1 Earned +1 2 +15.82 clear
4
JustinCook-Out Runs
123.68 Won +1 Earned +1 2 +7.74 clear
5
Rick Sr.OLD MAN
121.16 Lost 0 Earned +1 1 +5.22 clear
6
GlenDrake and Josh
118.56 Won +1 Earned +1 2 +2.62 clear
7
JohnSkatteboogie Nights
115.94 Lost 0 Missed 0 0 −2.62 short
8
RickyRevival
105.94 Won +1 Missed 0 1 −12.62 short
9
EricStarvin' Marvin
101.18 Lost 0 Missed 0 0 −17.38 short
10
TaylorPotty Train
100.18 Lost 0 Missed 0 0 −18.38 short
11
ConnorThe Disrespect Tour
97.42 Lost 0 Missed 0 0 −21.14 short
12
SeanTrouble on Dookie Island
97.20 Lost 0 Missed 0 0 −21.36 short

For teams above the line, the gap is measured against the highest score that missed. For teams below it, the gap is measured against the lowest score that earned the point.

Through Week 5

Season victory point tally

One victory point for each week a team scores in the league's top six. Matchup wins are separate and do not count here.

Top-six scoring victory points through Week 5
VP rankTeamVictory pointsPoints vs VP line
1
GlenDrake and Josh
4+105.56
1
WillChuba Libre
4+99.62
1
RickyRevival
4+22.00
4
JasonListen to the Podcast
3+28.64
4
DavidThird Years the Charm
3+28.28
4
Rick Sr.OLD MAN
3−17.96
4
JustinCook-Out Runs
3−46.26
8
JohnSkatteboogie Nights
2−20.32
8
ConnorThe Disrespect Tour
2−35.22
10
SeanTrouble on Dookie Island
1−55.90
10
EricStarvin' Marvin
1−84.98
12
TaylorPotty Train
0−59.64

Points vs VP line adds each week's score minus that week's sixth-place score. It shows how comfortably teams cleared or missed the line. Tied victory-point totals share a rank; cutoff margin orders ties for display, not as an official league tiebreaker.

Power scores blend completed results, lineup performance, current record, rest-of-season roster strength, and useful bench depth. They are comparative league ratings, not championship probabilities.