Week 9

Jason won the matchup. Why is Will No. 1?

Jason put 160.18 on Will, Glen won with 85.18, and Connor earned both points with 100.82. If you’re trying to pick a favorite for December, those three results send you in different directions. Will has the strongest projected lineup from here, Glen has the best all-play record, and Jason owns the actual standings. Week 9 made the arguments for all three a little clearer.

1↑1
Chuba Libre logo

Chuba Libre

Will Bertram

Week 9 resultLost to Jason 160.2–105.1

The case for Will starts after the final score

Jason beat Will by 55.12, and there wasn’t a better legal lineup hiding on Will’s bench. That’s a clean loss, not a coaching mystery. It still came with a victory point, partly because Bucky Irving put up 28.5 on a day when Josh Allen, Jahmyr Gibbs and Rashee Rice combined for 36.16.

The reason to put Will first is the next game, not the last one. FantasyPros gives him the league’s strongest projected starting eight, with four running backs worth using across the two RB and two FLEX spots. The risk is that it takes all four to make that lineup work; the reserves are better equipped to cover QB, WR and TE than a run of backfield absences.

🤖 What I would do

Keep the running-back surplus. Four startable backs are a feature in this league, even if the box score occasionally makes you want to put the entire roster in rice.

2↓1
Drake and Josh logo

Drake and Josh

Glen Cornell

Week 9 resultBeat Eric 85.2–74.1

Glen finally got the cheap win

Glen scored 134.90 and lost last week. This time 85.18 was enough. He missed the victory point, but if anyone has earned the right to accept a suspiciously affordable head-to-head win without asking for a receipt, it’s the guy who leads the league in all-play.

Brock Purdy supplied 25.28, but the receivers that usually give Glen his margin didn’t combine for a monster week. Denzel Boston’s 15.8 was a useful reminder that there’s still a FLEX decision to make. The sharper concern is next week: multiple stars and both rostered tight ends share the Week 11 bye. The overall outlook is still third; that one lineup won’t assemble itself.

🤖 What I would do

Sort out a Week 11 tight end now and keep Boston and Shakir until the lineup fits on paper. It’s a bye-week plan, not a confession of defeat.

3—
Listen to the Podcast logo

Listen to the Podcast

Jason Mac

Week 9 resultBeat Will 160.2–105.1

Jason has the better rebuttal and the better record

If Jason wants to read the score out loud before we discuss the model, fair enough. Puka Nacua and Matthew Golden gave him 67.4 by themselves, Brock Bowers added 22.3, and the 160.18 was both the weekly high and the best legal lineup Jason could have fielded. That’s what a No. 1 argument looks like on a Sunday.

He leads the league in both combined record and recency-weighted scoring. The only thing holding him at third is the forecast: FantasyPros puts his best eight sixth, and there isn’t much cushion behind them. Michael Penix Jr. is already in the model at QB; Jason isn’t being scored as if he left the position empty.

🤖 What I would do

Start shopping for a Week 11 quarterback before the rest of the league checks its calendar. Don’t spend like you’re replacing Lamar Jackson for the whole year when the first problem is one start.

4—
Trouble on Dookie Island logo

Trouble on Dookie Island

Sean Martyn

Week 9 resultBeat Ricky 123.7–114.5

Buttons has a top-two lineup hiding in fourth

A win over Ricky is the headline, but the thing I’d want to know as an opponent is whether 123.74 was the top of the range. Kenneth Walker III scored 36.3, Joe Burrow added 29.54, and Sean still has a route to a stronger lineup if Garrett Wilson returns to the value FantasyPros projects for him.

The roster now has a luxury: C.J. Stroud scored 35.36 on the bench, but that was only a 5.82-point upgrade over Burrow, not 35 points that went missing. Sean can make a quarterback decision or shop one from strength while leaning on the much more important question of who plays at WR.

🤖 What I would do

Listen if a QB-needy manager calls about Stroud, but ask for a receiver you’d actually start. A second great quarterback is useful; two backup receivers dressed up as a trade return are less so.

5—
OLD MAN logo

OLD MAN

Rick Myers

Week 9 resultBeat John 113.8–79.1

The standings are finally catching up with Rick Sr.

Rick Sr. has three head-to-head wins and six victory points. That’s how a team that’s been fourth-best in all-play can spend this much time looking up at the standings. Against Maconi he finally collected both points without needing an explanation of the median or a family discussion about strength of schedule.

Ja’Marr Chase’s 31.5 did the loud work, but the lineup is interesting because George Kittle and Travis Kelce can both fit alongside Chase, Malik Nabers and Nico Collins when healthy. The obvious place to improve is running back: those names can win the week, but they can’t fill the two mandatory RB slots.

🤖 What I would do

Price an RB upgrade against your actual FLEX, not against the idea that nobody needs two tight ends. In this format, sometimes you do.

6↑1
Revival logo

Revival

Ricky Myers

Week 9 resultLost to Sean 123.7–114.5

Ricky found the scoring even when the schedule stopped helping

CeeDee Lamb, Javonte Williams and Jonah Coleman combined for 74.7, and Ricky still drew the wrong opponent. This time the victory point did what it’s supposed to do: recognize that 114.48 was the third-highest score of the week, regardless of who was on the other side.

The encouraging part is that the starting lineup now has more than one way to land a big number, and the No. 2 bench gives Ricky choices without an immediate trade. The part worth watching is whether those choices can turn the weekly floor around. Before this result, he’d scored under 106 in four straight weeks.

🤖 What I would do

Use the depth while it’s an advantage. Don’t make a two-for-one just because a backup went off, but if somebody offers a clear FLEX upgrade, this is one of the few rosters that can afford to listen.

7↑1
Cook-Out Runs logo

Cook-Out Runs

Justin Veldhuis

Week 9 resultBeat David 96.5–66.9

V’s receivers did the work; Connor got the extra point

Christian Watson and Luther Burden III scored 50.8 between them. V beat Wells by nearly 30 and still missed the scoring point by 4.36. That’s a decent illustration of where this roster sits: dangerous enough to beat the team in front of it, not yet consistently above the rest of the league.

The ranks line up almost too neatly: seventh in projected starters, seventh in recency-weighted scoring, seventh in all-play. James Cook gives the lineup a dependable anchor, but with Caleb Williams, Burden and Emeka Egbuka all on bye in Week 10, this is a week to solve the empty slots before debating ceiling.

🤖 What I would do

Get the one-week QB first, then pick the FLEX from the available receivers. Don’t spend Tuesday improving an eighth slot when the first one is still empty.

8↓2
Skatteboogie Nights logo

Skatteboogie Nights

John Maconi

Week 9 resultLost to Rick Sr. 113.8–79.1

Maconi needs a second scoring engine

Dak Prescott and Isaiah Likely combined for 35.8. The rest of Maconi’s starters combined for 43.3. That’s how you land at 79.10 even with a good answer at tight end, and the best legal substitutions still wouldn’t have gotten him to 100.

At 9–9, this is fixable without treating one Sunday as a verdict on Justin Jefferson or Jonathan Taylor. But the projection puts Maconi eighth in starting strength, and he hasn’t cleared 116 since Week 2. Jalen Coker is in the model’s best eight, which makes him useful right now rather than merely the guy everybody remembers from the waiver bill.

🤖 What I would do

Look for an actual RB or WR upgrade if someone wants one of your tight ends. The right deal buys a second way to win, not the right to go back to staring at an empty FLEX.

9—
Third Years the Charm logo

Third Years the Charm

David Wells

Week 9 resultLost to Justin 96.5–66.9

Wells needs more than a better lineup card

There were points on the bench: Courtland Sutton had 15.5, Jayden Daniels 14.56 and Xavier Worthy 10.8. A legal reshuffle would have lifted Wells from 66.92 to 92.04. V scored 96.46, so even hindsight couldn’t quite rescue it.

Amon-Ra St. Brown and a deep enough group of running backs still give Wells something to build around. But the projected eight comes in tenth, and one receiver who can hold a FLEX spot every week would take more pressure off St. Brown than another Sunday morning coin flip.

🤖 What I would do

Start trade talks with the managers short on RBs, but keep the asking price at a WR you’d comfortably start. Otherwise you’re just moving the weekly guess from one position to another.

10—
The Disrespect Tour logo

The Disrespect Tour

Connor O'Brian

Week 9 resultBeat Taylor 100.8–74.8

Connor got the most out of 100.82

Connor cleared V by 4.36 for the last scoring point and beat Taylor for the other one. It’s the first time since Week 4 he’s reached 100. Getting both points out of it is a nice change for a team that’s spent a month trying to get back over that line.

Bijan Robinson did most of the heavy lifting, but DeMario Douglas and Mack Hollins combined for 27.8. That’s the useful development here: the depth receivers didn’t just show up in an emergency, they helped buy the scoring point. There’s another test coming with Bijan and Matthew Stafford both off in Week 11 and several projected starters carrying injury tags.

🤖 What I would do

Use Young to cover QB and save the roster move for running back. Bijan’s bye is not the time to discover your replacement plan was mostly a spreadsheet cell.

11—
Starvin' Marvin logo

Starvin' Marvin

Eric Lewandowski

Week 9 resultLost to Glen 85.2–74.1

Poles can win the bench rankings and still need a starter

Jordan Love scored 36.18 and Patrick Mahomes scored 16.48. The 19.70 difference was enough to flip the matchup with Glen in hindsight, which makes for a brutal box-score read. It doesn’t mean it was obviously wrong to start Mahomes before kickoff, and it definitely doesn’t mean Poles left all 36.18 unused.

The best bench in the league is real: Love, Germie Bernard, Rachaad White and Tyler Warren give Poles options at four positions, with future value elsewhere if injuries clear. But the projected starters and recent production both rank eleventh. The gap between those two rankings is the story: there’s talent to move around, and there are only eight seats.

🤖 What I would do

See what the market will pay for Love or Mahomes before you spend the rest of the season grading the one you didn’t start. The machine would also like to note that it has no personal stake in this debate. None whatsoever.

12—
7 Weeks of Breadsticks logo

7 Weeks of Breadsticks

Taylor Zorski

Week 9 resultLost to Connor 100.8–74.8

Taylor’s best player needs more help than this

Christian McCaffrey put up 22.7, and Taylor finished at 74.78. Michael Wilson was the second-highest scorer in that lineup at 12.0; Arizona has since confirmed he’s out for the season. After a 71.88 the week before, this is an existing scoring problem that just lost a potential solution.

The roster has multiple ways to choose a quarterback. The hard part is finding two receivers and a FLEX you want to run out every week. Taylor is twelfth in both actual and projected strength, so one favorable matchup probably won’t change the shape of this without another playable receiver.

🤖 What I would do

Use the next claim on a receiver with a route to real targets. You don’t need a fourth way to choose which quarterback watches McCaffrey try to score for everybody.

Week 9 scorecard

Weekly scores and victory points

A top-six score earns a victory point. Winning a matchup earns a separate standings point, so a matchup loss can still produce a victory point.

The victory-point line100.82 pts

Connor took the last victory point, 4.36 ahead of Justin.

Lost the matchup, earned a victory point: Ricky, Will

Won the matchup, missed the victory point: Justin, Glen

Week 9 scores and victory points, sorted by score
#TeamScoreMatchupVictory pointStandings pointsCutoff gap
1
JasonListen to the Podcast
160.18 Won +1 Earned +1 2 +63.72 clear
2
SeanTrouble on Dookie Island
123.74 Won +1 Earned +1 2 +27.28 clear
3
RickyRevival
114.48 Lost 0 Earned +1 1 +18.02 clear
4
Rick Sr.OLD MAN
113.76 Won +1 Earned +1 2 +17.30 clear
5
WillChuba Libre
105.06 Lost 0 Earned +1 1 +8.60 clear
6
ConnorThe Disrespect Tour
100.82 Won +1 Earned +1 2 +4.36 clear
7
JustinCook-Out Runs
96.46 Won +1 Missed 0 1 −4.36 short
8
GlenDrake and Josh
85.18 Won +1 Missed 0 1 −15.64 short
9
JohnSkatteboogie Nights
79.10 Lost 0 Missed 0 0 −21.72 short
10
Taylor7 Weeks of Breadsticks
74.78 Lost 0 Missed 0 0 −26.04 short
11
EricStarvin' Marvin
74.08 Lost 0 Missed 0 0 −26.74 short
12
DavidThird Years the Charm
66.92 Lost 0 Missed 0 0 −33.90 short

For teams above the line, the gap is measured against the highest score that missed. For teams below it, the gap is measured against the lowest score that earned the point.

Through Week 9

Season victory point tally

One victory point for each week a team scores in the league's top six. Matchup wins are separate and do not count here.

Top-six scoring victory points through Week 9
VP rankTeamVictory pointsPoints vs VP line
1
GlenDrake and Josh
7+153.54
1
JasonListen to the Podcast
7+123.32
3
WillChuba Libre
6+88.58
3
Rick Sr.OLD MAN
6+36.82
5
SeanTrouble on Dookie Island
5+12.60
5
RickyRevival
5+11.66
5
JustinCook-Out Runs
5−39.38
8
DavidThird Years the Charm
4−38.30
8
JohnSkatteboogie Nights
4−44.70
10
ConnorThe Disrespect Tour
3−95.92
11
EricStarvin' Marvin
2−141.56
12
Taylor7 Weeks of Breadsticks
0−151.20

Points vs VP line adds each week's score minus that week's sixth-place score. It shows how comfortably teams cleared or missed the line. Tied victory-point totals share a rank; cutoff margin orders ties for display, not as an official league tiebreaker.

Reporting sources and context

Fantasy scoring and ownership use the dated ESPN sync recorded below. Outlooks use the separately archived FantasyPros refresh. Injury and role reporting supplements those sources; league-chat reactions add color, not numerical model inputs. Older editions remain frozen under their original model.

The model uses 40% projected starting strength, 30% submitted scoring, 15% earned record, 10% all-play performance and 5% usable bench strength. Each position has a conservative maintenance floor from the third-best healthy, unlocked available rest-of-season projection, with at least three eligible options required. Additional replacements must be distinct third-or-lower options. The model rebuilds a legal eight and requires a droppable nonstarter for every addition; it protects injured assets and deducts lost reserve depth. It does not assume a trade, award the best waiver claim, or count unowned players as bench assets. These are independent replacement-level scenarios, not a simultaneous allocation of the same free agent to several teams, guaranteed claims, weekly streaming forecasts or proof of optimal strategy. Retained owned reserves determine bench rank using position-adjusted quality and legal coverage across known byes. Injured/IR assets retain provider-projected future value, not an invented return date. Lineup efficiency remains an active-roster hindsight measure, not pregame decision quality. Rank sensitivity is descriptive, not a confidence interval; power scores are comparative indexes, not win probabilities. Week 8 adopts these corrections; earlier editions retain their original models. Model v2-waiver-depth-2026-11-03. ESPN captured Nov 10, 5:20 AM PST; projection archive captured Nov 10, 5:22 AM PST. Archive capture time does not establish when the provider last changed a forecast.