Week 1

Will leads after an opening week that scrambled the forecast

Will takes the first in-season No. 1 after scoring 150.9 and beating David, but the first week has already scrambled the draft forecast. Connor's 153.3 was the league high, Justin's bench gives him a route upward, and Glen remains third despite an 0–2 start because his projected lineup is still among the strongest. One result is evidence, not a finished season.

Retrospective edition prepared October 6 from Week 1 results and a September 15 outlook snapshot. Later games, transactions, and projections are excluded from these rankings and writeups.

1↑2
Rotten Meat logo

Rotten Meat

Will Bertram

Week 1 resultBeat David 150.9–138.3

A first-week score with real backing

Will scored 150.9 against David, winning one of the league's strongest Week 1 matchups. Josh Allen supplied 35.7 points, Jahmyr Gibbs added 33.6, and Chuba Hubbard contributed 23.7. A roster that already projected near the top has now shown that its strongest pieces can all appear in the same lineup. That combination puts Rotten Meat first after the opening week.

The caution is still the bench, ranked eighth after the first snapshot of the season. Will did not need much from it to win this matchup, but a full season will ask more of the supporting group. The No. 1 case is not simply that 150.9 was a large number: the rest-of-season starting projection remains strong enough to support the result. One week can flatter a team, but it has not created a contradiction here.

2↑7
Sun God and Squad logo

Sun God and Squad

Justin Veldhuis

Week 1 resultLost to Connor 153.3–137.7

The first real upward surprise

Justin lost to Connor 153.3–137.7, but that score was still among the week's best. Caleb Williams produced 37.3 points and Christian Watson 32.7, turning a preseason roster that looked short on starter value into one of Week 1's livelier lineups. A loss in this particular matchup should not hide the amount of offense Justin put on the field.

The projection model has also moved toward the roster, and the bench now ranks first in the league. That depth does not guarantee another high-scoring Sunday, especially when two unusually large individual performances led this one. It does give Justin more ways to respond if the first lineup changes. Second place may feel aggressive for a 1–1 team, but it reflects both the production and the usable options that remain.

3↓2
Drake and Josh logo

Drake and Josh

Glen Cornell

Week 1 resultLost to Ricky 120.0–112.3

An 0–2 start that needs context

Glen lost 120.0–112.3 to Ricky, then landed below the league's top half of scorers. Jaxon Smith-Njigba and Zay Flowers combined for 52.2 points, so the receiver-first draft plan did show up. The rest of the starting lineup did not keep pace, leaving a team that was No. 1 in the preseason model with no standings points after its first game.

The ranking holds at third because the forward projection still sees one of the strongest starting groups in the league. That is not a claim the loss did not matter; the actual output pulls the score down, and an 0–2 start is real ground to recover. The fifth-ranked bench offers some flexibility, but Glen needs the full lineup to match what its best receivers provided in Week 1.

4↑3
Ranked 12th logo

Ranked 12th

Connor O'Brian

Week 1 resultBeat Justin 153.3–137.7

The biggest score belongs to Connor

Connor posted the league's highest Week 1 total, 153.3, and needed most of it to beat Justin's 137.7. Bijan Robinson opened with 31.3 points, Jaxson Dart delivered 26.6, and Trey McBride added 24.5. That is a useful answer to the preseason model's middle-of-the-pack assessment: the roster has already shown a way to win a high-output matchup.

Fourth, rather than first, reflects the difference between what happened once and what the available projections expect next. The future starting group is not yet as highly rated as Will's or Glen's, and the bench sits ninth. Connor has the week's strongest evidence but less modeled cover if those first-week peaks soften. Another result like this would change the balance quickly.

5↓1
OLD MAN logo

OLD MAN

Rick Myers

Week 1 resultLost to Eric 111.2–101.9

A loss with more underneath it

Rick Sr. lost 111.2–101.9 to Eric, despite David Montgomery's 28.9 points and Nico Collins's 21.2. The score was near the bottom half of the league, so the 0–2 record is not just an unlucky matchup. Several of the roster's premium receivers did not produce a collective advantage in this first outing.

The September 15 outlook is considerably kinder than the Week 1 result. OLD MAN still has an upper-tier projected starting group and a fourth-ranked bench, which is why it stays fifth rather than following the record downward. Rick Sr.'s 98% manager grade also suggests there was little obvious production stranded on the bench. This looks more like a slow week from the available starters than a lineup-management problem.

6↑6
The Place That Makes Me Happy logo

The Place That Makes Me Happy

Ricky Myers

Week 1 resultBeat Glen 120.0–112.3

A win that changes the opening conversation

Ricky was the preseason model's last-ranked team, then beat Glen 120.0–112.3 and cleared the league's top-half scoring line. Trevor Lawrence scored 26.1, Javonte Williams 24.2, and Parker Washington 19.3. None of those were required to rescue a single failing position; together they made a complete enough lineup to win.

The forward projection is still closer to the middle of the league than the 2–0 record suggests. That is why Ricky rises to sixth instead of leaping into the top group. The second-ranked bench adds a reason to keep watching, however. The opening result showed more breadth than the draft estimate expected, and the reserve options could help sustain it if the first-week contributors do not all repeat.

7↑4
Touchdown My Pants logo

Touchdown My Pants

Sean Martyn

Week 1 resultLost to Taylor 106.4–95.4

One standout back, too few answers

Kenneth Walker III scored 34.1 for Sean, but the team finished at 95.4 and lost to Taylor's 106.4. Joe Burrow and Garrett Wilson were less productive than the lineup needed, and the rest of the group did not bridge the gap. One great running back week can win a matchup in this format; this time it mostly made a low total less severe.

The roster's forward outlook remains stronger than its Week 1 showing, keeping Sean seventh despite the 0–2 start. The sixth-ranked bench offers some possible repairs, but this team needs points from more than one premium pick. Week 1 does not settle the case for Saquon Barkley, Wilson, or the receiver depth. It does establish the early problem: a single big scorer was not enough to make the full starting eight competitive.

8↓3
Skatteboogie Nights logo

Skatteboogie Nights

John Maconi

Week 1 resultBeat Jason 140.7–113.2

A win that raises the floor question

John beat Jason 140.7–113.2, powered by D'Andre Swift's 32.4, Isaiah Likely's 27.8, and Jonathan Taylor's 25.1. That gave Skatteboogie Nights both matchup and top-half wins. It also showed how much punch the roster can have when several non-obvious starting choices hit together.

The model stays cautious at eighth because the rest-of-season starting projection is far weaker than this one result. John ranks third in bench depth, so the roster has alternatives, but the projection question is whether those alternatives amount to durable weekly starters. The 88% manager grade leaves some room for better lineup conversion as well. Week 1 is a strong answer on the scoreboard, not yet a complete answer about the roster's season-long level.

9↑1
Listen to the Podcast logo

Listen to the Podcast

Jason Mac

Week 1 resultLost to John 140.7–113.2

Good contributions, not enough total

Chris Olave's 28.2 and Lamar Jackson's 25.0 gave Jason two strong starters, yet the team lost 140.7–113.2 to John and missed the league's top-half scoring line. This was not a case of all the stars disappearing; it was a case of the supporting slots failing to match an opponent with several high-end performances.

The roster is ninth in power with a ninth-ranked bench. The 97% manager grade suggests Jason did not leave a much better version of Week 1 unused. That makes improvement more dependent on the available players producing more, rather than simply choosing different ones. Puka Nacua and Brock Bowers still give the lineup notable talent in the forward view, so there is a path upward even after an 0–2 opening.

10↓8
Third Years the Charm logo

Third Years the Charm

David Wells

Week 1 resultLost to Will 150.9–138.3

An excellent score in a losing matchup

David scored 138.3, a total that would have won several Week 1 matchups, but drew Will's 150.9 and took the head-to-head loss. Derrick Henry delivered 35.3, Amon-Ra St. Brown 28.7, and Dallas Goedert 23.7. The top-half scoring win gives David a 1–1 start rather than the full penalty of facing the week's eventual No. 1 team.

The ranking falls to tenth because the September 15 forward model has cooled sharply on the projected starters, not because 138.3 was a poor performance. The seventh-ranked bench is also less formidable than the preseason estimate. One week of strong output argues for patience, while the changed projection argues against assuming this exact scoring mix will repeat. Both signals belong in the first-week read.

11↓3
DK’s Bananaland logo

DK’s Bananaland

Eric Lewandowski

Week 1 resultBeat Rick Sr. 111.2–101.9

A first win, with a modest total

Eric beat Rick Sr. 111.2–101.9, led by Justin Jefferson's 31.2 points. Chase Brown and Travis Etienne Jr. both added useful RB scores, giving the lineup enough to win its assigned matchup. The score was still below the league's top-half line, leaving Eric 1–1 in the dual-result standings.

The opening win is real, but the model sees a weaker rest-of-season starting group than most opponents. The ninth-ranked bench does not currently make up the difference. That makes this roster an early test of whether a few top players can consistently compensate for less certain supporting production. Eric starts eleventh rather than last because Week 1 at least supplied a result, even if it did not establish a convincing scoring pace.

12↓6
Potty Train logo

Potty Train

Taylor Zorski

Week 1 resultBeat Sean 106.4–95.4

Jeanty shines in a narrow opening win

Taylor beat Sean 106.4–95.4 behind Ashton Jeanty's 32.7 and Jalen Hurts's 24.7. It was enough for the matchup, but not for a top-half scoring win, so the record opens at 1–1. The size of Jeanty's contribution also shows how much the rest of the lineup still had to find: Christian McCaffrey scored 13.8 against an 18.5 projection.

Potty Train closes the first list because the September outlook has the weakest projected starting group and little distinctive bench value. The 97% manager grade means there was not an obvious pile of unused Week 1 points. This is a roster-level forecast, not a criticism of the win. Jeanty gave Taylor an opening path; a better full-lineup result is needed to change the broader reading.

Week 1 scorecard

Weekly scores and victory points

A top-six score earns a victory point. Winning a matchup earns a separate standings point, so a matchup loss can still produce a victory point.

The victory-point line120.00 pts

Ricky took the last victory point, 6.84 ahead of Jason.

Lost the matchup, earned a victory point: David, Justin

Won the matchup, missed the victory point: Eric, Taylor

Week 1 scores and victory points, sorted by score
#TeamScoreMatchupVictory pointStandings pointsCutoff gap
1
ConnorRanked 12th
153.30 Won +1 Earned +1 2 +40.14 clear
2
WillRotten Meat
150.86 Won +1 Earned +1 2 +37.70 clear
3
JohnSkatteboogie Nights
140.70 Won +1 Earned +1 2 +27.54 clear
4
DavidThird Years the Charm
138.26 Lost 0 Earned +1 1 +25.10 clear
5
JustinSun God and Squad
137.66 Lost 0 Earned +1 1 +24.50 clear
6
RickyThe Place That Makes Me Happy
120.00 Won +1 Earned +1 2 +6.84 clear
7
JasonListen to the Podcast
113.16 Lost 0 Missed 0 0 −6.84 short
8
GlenDrake and Josh
112.30 Lost 0 Missed 0 0 −7.70 short
9
EricDK’s Bananaland
111.16 Won +1 Missed 0 1 −8.84 short
10
TaylorPotty Train
106.42 Won +1 Missed 0 1 −13.58 short
11
Rick Sr.OLD MAN
101.92 Lost 0 Missed 0 0 −18.08 short
12
SeanTouchdown My Pants
95.36 Lost 0 Missed 0 0 −24.64 short

For teams above the line, the gap is measured against the highest score that missed. For teams below it, the gap is measured against the lowest score that earned the point.

Through Week 1

Season victory point tally

One victory point for each week a team scores in the league's top six. Matchup wins are separate and do not count here.

Top-six scoring victory points through Week 1
VP rankTeamVictory pointsPoints vs VP line
1
ConnorRanked 12th
1+33.30
1
WillRotten Meat
1+30.86
1
JohnSkatteboogie Nights
1+20.70
1
DavidThird Years the Charm
1+18.26
1
JustinSun God and Squad
1+17.66
1
RickyThe Place That Makes Me Happy
10.00
7
JasonListen to the Podcast
0−6.84
7
GlenDrake and Josh
0−7.70
7
EricDK’s Bananaland
0−8.84
7
TaylorPotty Train
0−13.58
7
Rick Sr.OLD MAN
0−18.08
7
SeanTouchdown My Pants
0−24.64

Points vs VP line adds each week's score minus that week's sixth-place score. It shows how comfortably teams cleared or missed the line. Tied victory-point totals share a rank; cutoff margin orders ties for display, not as an official league tiebreaker.

Power scores blend completed results, lineup performance, current record, rest-of-season roster strength, and useful bench depth. They are comparative league ratings, not championship probabilities.